Artisan Bakery & Café · Middletown

Every morning begins with flour, fire, and something worth remembering.

Hand-shaped loaves. Seasonal pastries. Coffee poured with intention. Jacobson's Bakery is Middletown's destination for baked goods made the way they should be — slowly, by hand, with real ingredients.

78
Montgomery St
100%
Artisan Baked
Daily
Fresh Batches
Freshly baked artisan bread on a wooden counter at Jacobson's Bakery
Open Now Fresh sourdough out of the oven every morning at 6 AM.
Baked with conviction,
served with warmth.
Baker shaping sourdough dough by hand
Pastries displayed in a glass case at Jacobson's

Jacobson's Bakery sits quietly on Montgomery Street in Middletown — not because we're shy, but because the work speaks for itself. Every loaf, every croissant, every cup of coffee is made the way it ought to be: with patience, real ingredients, and a respect for craft that can't be rushed.

Our bakers arrive before dawn. The ovens are fired up. The sourdough starter — kept alive for years — is fed and folded. By the time the street wakes up, the smell of butter and wheat is already filling the room, and the first customers are pushing the door open.

We don't outsource. We don't use shortcuts. What you see on the shelf is what we made, in-house, that morning. That's the promise we make to everyone who walks through our door.

The Jacobson Family
Founders & Bakers, Middletown
From the oven to
your table.
Every item is baked fresh each morning using traditional methods and the finest locally sourced ingredients.
Golden sourdough loaf with a flour-dusted crust
Signature
Sourdough Loaves
Wild-yeast fermented for 24 hours. Crusty exterior, open crumb, tangy depth. Our most ordered item — and for good reason.
Assorted buttery pastries and croissants on a marble surface
Pastries
Hand-Layered Pastries
Butter croissants, almond pain au chocolat, fruit tarts — each one folded by hand, laminated properly, and baked to a shatteringly crisp finish.
Barista pouring coffee into a ceramic cup at Jacobson's Bakery
Beverages
Coffee & Café Drinks
Single-origin espresso, pour-over, and seasonal specials. Paired with our pastries, it's the kind of morning ritual worth keeping.
Rustic whole grain and seeded bread loaves on a wooden board
Breads
Artisan & Seeded Breads
Whole grain, rye, multigrain — dense, nourishing loaves built for slicing thick and slathering with local butter.
Slice of rich chocolate layer cake on a ceramic plate
Desserts
Cakes & Sweet Treats
Seasonal cakes, cheesecakes, and small-batch desserts. Order ahead for celebrations — we bake them fresh, not frozen.
Breakfast spread with bread, butter, jam, and coffee on a wooden table
Special Orders
Custom & Catering
Wedding cakes, event platters, holiday boxes. Tell us what you need — we'll bake it and make sure it arrives perfect.
Baked Before Dawn
Our ovens fire up at 4 AM so everything is fresh and warm when you walk in.
Real Ingredients
No preservatives, no shortcuts. Just flour, water, salt, butter, and time.
Made with Care
Every batch is hand-shaped, watched, and removed from the oven at exactly the right moment.
A Middletown Staple
We're proud to be part of this community — your neighborhood bakery, every day.
Loved by the
neighborhood.
"I've been coming here every Saturday for years. The sourdough is unmatched in Middletown — and the coffee is the kind that actually makes your morning better."
M
Margaret L.
Middletown resident
"We ordered a custom cake for our wedding and it was absolutely stunning — and delicious. The team at Jacobson's went above and beyond. Everyone at the reception asked where we got it."
D
Daniel & Priya
Wedding clients
"The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, the pastries are incredible, and the staff treats you like a regular from the first visit. This place is a gem — don't let anyone tell you otherwise."
S
Sarah K.
Weekly visitor

Come taste what real baking feels like.

Walk in any morning and let the smell do the rest. Or call ahead to reserve a custom order — we're always happy to help.

Find us on
Montgomery Street.

Get in Touch

Address
78 Montgomery St, Middletown
10940-4023, United States
Hours
Monday – Friday6:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Saturday7:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Sunday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM

Send Us a Message

Message Sent!

Thank you for reaching out. We'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Is this your business?This is my business